Triangles on a ball
The question
On flat paper the angles of every triangle add up to 180°, and a² + b² = c² in every right triangle. Draw a triangle on a ball instead. Is either rule still true?
Try the experiment before reading on. There’s no wrong way to explore.
Experiment
Triangles on curved surfaces
Drag the corners. On a flat plane the angles add up to 180°; on a sphere they add up to more, and in the hyperbolic plane to less.
Drag a corner to move it; drag anywhere else to turn the sphere. The sides are arcs of great circles — the shortest paths on a sphere.
- ∠A80.6°
- ∠B66.6°
- ∠C64.7°
∠A + ∠B + ∠C = 212.0°
- Angle excess (sum − 180°)
- 32.0° = 0.558 rad
- Area, measured numerically
- 0.558 R²
- Share of the whole sphere (area ÷ 4πR²)
- 4.44 %
∠A + ∠B + ∠C − π = Area / R²On a sphere of radius R, the excess in radians equals the area divided by R². The area is computed separately, by numerical integration, so the match is a check rather than an assumption.
∠A + ∠B + ∠C − π = K · Area
| Flat plane | K = 0 | ∠A+∠B+∠C = 180° |
|---|---|---|
| Sphere | K = 1/R² | ∠A+∠B+∠C > 180° |
| Hyperbolic plane | K = −1 | ∠A+∠B+∠C < 180° |
This is a first glimpse of the Gauss–Bonnet theorem: for a triangle whose sides are geodesics (shortest paths), the angle sum minus π equals the total curvature inside it. Here the curvature K is the same everywhere; on other surfaces you add up (integrate) K over the area.
Hints, if you want them
What’s going on
What’s going on
On a sphere the "straight lines" are great circles — circles whose centre is the centre of the sphere, like the equator. The walk in the first hint makes a triangle with three right angles: its angles add up to .
Albert Girard found the rule in 1629. On a sphere of radius , a triangle with angles (in radians) has
Our triangle covers one eighth of the sphere, so its area is , and the excess is — exactly the extra .
Pythagoras fails too. All three sides of that triangle are quarter-circles of the same length , so . The spherical version of the theorem is
and for small triangles it is very close to — which is why flat geometry works so well for drawing a field or a town, even though the Earth is round.
The difference between the angle sum and measures how curved a surface is. On a saddle-shaped surface — the hyperbolic plane — triangles have angle sums less than . Gauss, Bolyai, Lobachevsky and Riemann turned these observations into non-Euclidean geometry, and Einstein used curved geometry to describe gravity.
Where this leads
- Early undergraduate · Lesson availableNon-Euclidean geometry: spherical and hyperbolicWhat happens when the parallel postulate fails: geometry on the sphere, the Poincaré disc and half-plane models of the hyperbolic plane, angle sums and area, curvature as the measure of the difference, and the independence of the parallel postulate.
- Advanced undergraduate · Lesson availableDifferential geometry of curves and surfacesCurvature and torsion of space curves, the first and second fundamental forms of surfaces, Gaussian and mean curvature, Gauss's Theorema Egregium, geodesics and the Gauss–Bonnet theorem.
- First-year graduate · Lesson availableRiemannian geometryCurved spaces studied from the inside: Riemannian metrics, the Levi-Civita connection, geodesics and the exponential map, curvature tensors, Jacobi fields, the global Gauss–Bonnet theorem, Hopf–Rinow, and comparison theorems such as Bonnet–Myers.