Sour, slippery and in between
Squeeze a lemon and you get a sharply sour juice. Rub soapy water between your fingers and it feels slippery. Your stomach holds a liquid strong enough to break down a meal; a tablet from a pharmacy can calm it when it causes heartburn. A gardener in Japan or Cornwall finds that the same hydrangea bush flowers blue in one garden and pink in another. And red cabbage, cooked with a splash of vinegar, turns a brighter red.
All of these are about two great families of substances: acids and bases. They are everywhere, in your kitchen, your cleaning cupboard, your body, the soil and the sea. This lesson shows how chemists recognise them, measure them with the pH scale, and use one to cancel out the other.
Long before anyone knew what was inside an atom, people sorted these substances by everyday clues: acidic foods such as lemons, vinegar and sour milk are sour; alkaline things such as soap feel slippery. Chemists never use clues like these to identify an unknown chemical. Many acids and alkalis burn skin and eyes, which is why the corrosion pictogram from Working safely with chemicals appears on strong ones. Instead, chemists use colour-changing indicators and electronic pH meters.
Acids, bases and alkalis
In the 1880s the Swedish chemist Svante Arrhenius suggested a simple explanation for what acids have in common.
Definition— acid
An acid is a substance that releases hydrogen ions, H⁺, when it dissolves in water. Examples are citric acid (in lemons and oranges), ethanoic acid (in vinegar), carbonic acid (in fizzy water) and hydrochloric acid (in your stomach).
Definition— base and alkali
A base is a substance that reacts with an acid and cancels out its acidity. A base that dissolves in water is called an alkali; alkalis release hydroxide ions, OH⁻, in water. Examples are sodium hydrogencarbonate (baking soda), calcium carbonate (chalk, and many antacid tablets), soap, and the sodium hydroxide in oven cleaners.
A solution that is neither acidic nor alkaline, such as pure water or salt water, is neutral.
The pH scale
In 1909 the Danish chemist Søren Sørensen, working at the Carlsberg Laboratory in Copenhagen, where chemists studied the enzymes used in brewing, introduced a neat way of describing how acidic or alkaline a solution is: its pH.
Definition— pH
The pH of a solution is a number, usually between 0 and 14, that measures how acidic or alkaline it is. At 25 °C, a pH below 7 is acidic, exactly 7 is neutral, and above 7 is alkaline. The lower the pH, the more hydrogen ions the solution contains: each step down the scale means ten times as many hydrogen ions.
That "ten times" is what makes pH so useful, and so easy to misread. Lemon juice, at pH 2, is not a little more acidic than black coffee at pH 5: it has times as many hydrogen ions.
Counting in tens
This program takes some typical pH values and works out how many hydrogen ions each liquid has compared with pure water. Each pH step below 7 multiplies the number by 10, and each step above 7 divides it by 10, so the comparison is .
# Typical pH values (they vary from sample to sample)
liquids = [
("lemon juice", 2.0),
("vinegar", 3.0),
("black coffee", 5.0),
("milk", 6.5),
("pure water", 7.0),
("sea water", 8.1),
("baking-soda solution", 8.3),
("soapy water", 10.0),
]
print(f"{'liquid':22} {'pH':>4} hydrogen ions compared with pure water")
for name, pH in liquids:
times = 10 ** (7 - pH) # each pH step is a factor of 10
if pH == 7.0:
print(f"{name:22} {pH:4.1f} the same: neutral")
elif times > 1:
print(f"{name:22} {pH:4.1f} {times:,.0f} times as many")
else:
print(f"{name:22} {pH:4.1f} 1/{1 / times:,.0f} as many")
# The ocean: surface pH fell from about 8.2 to about 8.1 since the 1800s
change = 10 ** (8.2 - 8.1)
print(f"\nOcean, pH 8.2 -> 8.1: {change:.2f} times as many hydrogen ions,")
print(f"that is {100 * (change - 1):.0f} % more")Try adding your own liquids: stomach acid at about pH 1.5, or blood at 7.4.
Indicators, and a red-cabbage experiment
Definition— indicator
An indicator is a substance that changes colour depending on whether it is in an acid or an alkali, or, for some indicators, on the exact pH.
People have used plant colours as indicators for centuries. In the 1660s the Irish-born chemist Robert Boyle described how the purple juice of violets turns red in acids and green in alkalis. Litmus, a dye made from lichens, turns red in acid and blue in alkali, and is still used in school laboratories as paper strips. Universal indicator is a mixture of dyes that gives a different colour for almost every pH, like a rainbow. Nature is full of indicators: the colours of red cabbage, red onions, blackberries and hydrangea flowers all depend on pH, and a yellow turmeric stain from a curry turns reddish-brown when it is washed with alkaline soap.
Make a red-cabbage indicator, with an adult
This is the one experiment in this lesson. It uses only food from the kitchen, and it needs an adult for the knife and the hot water.
You need: about a quarter of a red cabbage; a heatproof jug or bowl; hot water from a kettle; a sieve; three clear glasses or jars; labels; vinegar; lemon juice; baking soda; a teaspoon; a tray to work on.
- An adult chops the cabbage into small pieces and puts them in the heatproof jug.
- An adult pours hot water from the kettle over the cabbage, just enough to cover it. Leave it for about 15 minutes, stirring now and then, until the water is a deep purple and has cooled down.
- Pour it through the sieve into a clean jug. The purple liquid is your indicator.
- Pour indicator into the three glasses until each is about a quarter full, and label them "vinegar", "lemon juice" and "baking soda".
- Add a teaspoon of vinegar to the first glass and a teaspoon of lemon juice to the second. Stir half a teaspoon of baking soda into a little water, and add a teaspoon of that solution to the third.
- Compare the colours with each other and with the purple indicator, and write down what you see.
What to expect. The vinegar and lemon juice turn the indicator pink to red, because they are acidic; the baking-soda solution turns it blue to blue-green, because it is alkaline. The exact shades depend on the cabbage and on your tap water. The colour comes from pigments called anthocyanins, whose molecules change shape, and so colour, as they gain or lose hydrogen ions.
Staying safe. Test only these three kitchen liquids. Never test cleaning products, such as bleach, oven cleaner or drain cleaner, with your indicator: they are corrosive and can burn skin and eyes. Don't drink the mixtures; they are an experiment, not food. When you have finished, pour everything down the sink with plenty of water, wash the glasses, wipe up any drips (cabbage juice stains) and wash your hands.
Neutralisation: cancelling acids out
When an acid and a base react, they cancel each other out. The hydrogen ions from the acid join the hydroxide ions from the alkali to make water, H⁺ + OH⁻ → H₂O, and what is left is a salt (to a chemist, "salt" means any compound made this way, not only table salt).
Definition— neutralisation
Neutralisation is the reaction of an acid with a base, which makes a salt and water (and, if the base is a carbonate or hydrogencarbonate, carbon dioxide too):
The textbook example is hydrochloric acid with sodium hydroxide: HCl + NaOH → NaCl + H₂O, which makes ordinary table salt and water. Both reactants are corrosive and are used only in laboratories, but neutralisation happens safely all around you:
- Antacids. Heartburn and indigestion can come from too much stomach acid. Antacid tablets contain bases such as calcium carbonate, magnesium hydroxide or sodium hydrogencarbonate, which neutralise some of it. With calcium carbonate, the reaction is CaCO₃ + 2HCl → CaCl₂ + H₂O + CO₂; that carbon dioxide is why antacids can make you burp.
- Teeth. Bacteria in your mouth turn sugar into acids. Below about pH 5.5, those acids start to dissolve tooth enamel. Saliva slowly neutralises them, and brushing with toothpaste removes the bacteria and adds fluoride, which makes enamel tougher.
- Gardens and farms. Many crops grow poorly in very acidic soil. Farmers and gardeners spread powdered limestone (calcium carbonate) or lime to neutralise it. In acidic soil, hydrangeas can take up aluminium, which makes their flowers blue; in alkaline soil, they are pink.
- Baking. Baking powder is a base (baking soda) and a dry acid mixed together. Once wet, they neutralise each other and release the carbon dioxide that makes a cake rise, as you saw in Chemical reactions.
Acids and bases in your body
Your body keeps very different pH values in different places. Your stomach is strongly acidic, around pH 1.5 to 3.5, which helps to break down proteins and kills most of the microbes you swallow; its lining is protected by a layer of mucus. Your skin is mildly acidic, around pH 5, which helps to keep harmful bacteria at bay. Your blood, by contrast, is kept between pH 7.35 and 7.45 all the time, by dissolved substances called buffers that soak up extra acid or base. How buffers work is explained in Acids, bases and buffers.
Acid rain and an acidifying ocean
Even clean rain is slightly acidic, at about pH 5.6, because carbon dioxide from the air dissolves in it to form a weak acid, carbonic acid.
Acid rain is rain that is much more acidic than that, often with a pH between 4 and 5. It happens when power stations, factories and vehicles burn coal and oil that contain sulfur, and when hot engines and furnaces make nitrogen oxides. These gases dissolve in clouds to make sulfuric and nitric acids. In the 1970s and 1980s acid rain damaged forests, killed fish in lakes in Scandinavia, Canada and the north-eastern United States, and ate away at limestone buildings and statues. Countries responded together: in 1979 they signed the Convention on Long-range Transboundary Air Pollution, through the United Nations Economic Commission for Europe; power stations fitted equipment to remove sulfur from their smoke, and fuels were made with much less sulfur. Sulfur pollution, and the acidity of rain, fell steeply in Europe and North America, and more recently in China. Acid rain is one of the great success stories of environmental chemistry.
The ocean is a different story, and still unfolding. The sea absorbs roughly a quarter of the carbon dioxide that people release by burning fuels, and that carbon dioxide forms carbonic acid in seawater. Since the 1800s the average pH of the surface ocean has fallen from about 8.2 to about 8.1, which, as the program showed, is about 26 % more hydrogen ions. This is called ocean acidification. It makes it harder for corals, oysters, mussels and tiny sea snails to build their shells and skeletons from calcium carbonate. Scientists around the world measure it continuously, from ships and from buoys moored in the open sea. You can read more in Environmental chemistry.
Misconception
"Ocean acidification means the sea is turning into acid." Seawater is still alkaline, at about pH 8.1. "Acidification" means it is moving towards the acidic end of the scale. Even so, a small change in pH is a large change in hydrogen ions, and sea life is sensitive to it.
Common misconceptions
Misconception
"All acids are dangerous and burn." Some do: concentrated acids are corrosive, and they belong in a laboratory. But many acids are weak or very dilute: you eat citric acid in oranges and ascorbic acid, vitamin C, every day. Equally, alkalis are not safe just because they are not acids: oven cleaner and drain cleaner are among the most dangerous products in a home.
Misconception
"pH 4 is just a little more acidic than pH 5." Each step is a factor of ten: pH 4 has ten times as many hydrogen ions as pH 5, and pH 3 has a hundred times as many.
Misconception
"Neutralising means making something harmless." Neutralisation makes a salt and water, and the salt has its own properties. Most are harmless, but not all, and the reaction can release heat. That is why, for a splash on skin or in the eyes, the rule is plenty of water, never another chemical.
Misconception
"Pure water has no ions in it." Even the purest water splits very slightly into H⁺ and OH⁻ ions, in equal numbers. That is what makes it neutral, and it is why pure water has a pH at all.
Exercises
These exercises practise the pH scale, indicators and neutralisation. One asks you to write a little Python.
1. Acids and bases around us
Warm-upHumanA glass of orange juice has a pH of about 3.5. What does that tell you?
2. Acids and bases around us
CoreHumanSolution A has pH 3 and solution B has pH 5. How many times as many hydrogen ions does solution A have as solution B?
3. Acids and bases around us
Warm-upHumanIn the red-cabbage experiment, what colour does the purple indicator turn when baking-soda solution is added, and why?
4. Acids and bases around us
CoreHumanHow does an antacid tablet containing calcium carbonate relieve heartburn caused by too much stomach acid?
5. Acids and bases around us
CoreHumanWhich of these are alkaline? Select all that apply. (Use the pH scale figure in the lesson.)
6. Acids and bases around us
Warm-upHumanWhat is the general name for a substance, such as litmus or red-cabbage juice, that changes colour to show whether a solution is acidic or alkaline? (One word.)
7. Acids and bases around us
StretchHumanSince the 1800s, the average pH of the surface ocean has fallen from about 8.2 to about 8.1. Which statement is correct?
8. Acids and bases around us
CoreComputationalComplete the function classify(pH) so that it returns "acidic" for a pH below 7, "neutral" for a pH of exactly 7, and "alkaline" for a pH above 7 (taking the temperature to be 25 °C).
Further reading and resources
- PhET: pH Scale · University of Colorado BoulderA free simulation. Test everyday liquids, add water, and watch the pH and the hydrogen ions change.
- NOAA Ocean Acidification ProgramThe United States' ocean agency explains how the ocean's chemistry is changing and how it is measured.
- Acid Rain · US Environmental Protection AgencyWhat acid rain is, what it did, and how cutting sulfur emissions reduced it.
- PubChemLook up "citric acid", "sodium hydrogencarbonate" or "cyanidin" (the colour in red cabbage) to see their structures and safety information.