Skip to content
LumenaryAcademy
Organic 75 min

Carbonyl and aromatic chemistry

The polarised C=O group and its additions, substitutions, condensations and enolates; the aromatic ring and its substitutions; and why medicines and dyes are built from both.

Code tested · 5AI-draftedAwaiting review by a chemist

Your guides: Chloe · The Chemist, Margaret · The Analyst, Gideon · The Sceptic

MotivationH

Two families that built modern chemistry

In 1856 William Henry Perkin, an eighteen-year-old student in London, was trying to make the antimalarial quinine from coal-tar chemicals. He failed, and found instead a purple dye, mauveine, which he went on to manufacture. Within a few decades synthetic dyes had grown into a large industry in Britain, Germany and Switzerland, and the companies built on them later turned to medicines. Mauveine, like nearly every dye and drug that followed, is made of two kinds of building block: aromatic rings and groups containing the carbonyl group, C=O.

The pattern holds today. Benzene is the most common ring in marketed medicines (Taylor and colleagues, 2014); making an amide, a carbonyl compound, is the reaction medicinal chemists run most often (Brown and Boström, 2016); paracetamol, aspirin and ibuprofen are each an aromatic ring carrying carbonyl groups. Proteins are chains of amides, sugars are carbonyl compounds in disguise, and the colour of indigo, alizarin and food dyes comes from carbonyls and rings working together.

This lesson explains why. With the curly arrows of Reaction mechanisms and the orbitals of Molecular orbitals, the chemistry of both families follows from a few ideas: a polarised π bond with a low-lying empty orbital, and a ring of six π electrons that would rather be substituted than broken.

IntuitionH

The carbonyl group: a polarised double bond

Oxygen is more electronegative than carbon, so the C=O bond is polarised, Cδ+=Oδ−. Two consequences follow. Nucleophiles attack the carbon; acids and electrophiles bind to the oxygen, which makes the carbon even more electron-poor. And because the π bond is weaker than the σ bond, a nucleophile can add to carbon while the π electrons retreat onto oxygen, giving a tetrahedral alkoxide.

CORRNuCNuRRO−−δ+δ−107°planar carbonyl, sp²tetrahedral alkoxide, sp³
Nucleophilic addition to a carbonyl group, seen with the carbonyl's plane edge-on. The nucleophile approaches from above the plane at about 107° to the C=O bond (the Bürgi–Dunitz angle), where the π* orbital is largest. One curly arrow forms the new bond to carbon; the other moves the π electrons onto oxygen. The planar sp² carbon becomes tetrahedral.

Hückel theory with a heteroatom makes the picture quantitative. Oxygen's orbital is given a lower energy, αO=α+hβ\alpha_\mathrm{O} = \alpha + h\beta with h≈1h \approx 1, and the 2 × 2 matrix of Molecular orbitals does the rest. The same code handles propenal, CH₂=CH–CH=O, where a C=C bond is conjugated with the carbonyl.

python
import numpy as np

def huckel(n_atoms, bonds, h=None):
    """Hueckel pi orbitals with heteroatoms. The matrix has h_i on the diagonal (alpha_i = alpha + h_i beta)
    and k_ij for each bond (beta_ij = k_ij beta). Returns x, with E = alpha + x beta, most bonding first,
    and the coefficients (one MO per column)."""
    A = np.zeros((n_atoms, n_atoms))
    for i, j, k in bonds:
        A[i, j] = A[j, i] = k
    for i, hi in (h or {}).items():
        A[i, i] = hi
    x, C = np.linalg.eigh(A)
    return x[::-1], C[:, ::-1]

def pi_charges(C, n_electrons):
    occ = np.zeros(C.shape[1])
    occ[: n_electrons // 2] = 2
    return 1 - (C**2 * occ).sum(axis=1)     # each atom brings one pi electron, minus what it holds

# Methanal, H2C=O: atom 0 = C, atom 1 = O, with h_O = 1 (a common textbook value for carbonyl oxygen).
x, C = huckel(2, [(0, 1, 1.0)], {1: 1.0})
q = pi_charges(C, 2)
print("methanal        C      O")
print(f"pi  (x = {x[0]:+.2f}) {abs(C[0, 0]):5.2f}  {abs(C[1, 0]):5.2f}")
print(f"pi* (x = {x[1]:+.2f}) {abs(C[0, 1]):5.2f}  {abs(C[1, 1]):5.2f}   <- the LUMO")
print(f"pi charge      {q[0]:+5.2f}  {q[1]:+5.2f}")

# Propenal, CH2=CH-CH=O: atoms O, C1 (the carbonyl carbon), C2, C3 (the far end of the C=C)
x, C = huckel(4, [(0, 1, 1.0), (1, 2, 1.0), (2, 3, 1.0)], {0: 1.0})
q = pi_charges(C, 4)
print("\npropenal          O     C1     C2     C3")
print("pi charge   " + "".join(f"{v:+7.2f}" for v in q))
print("LUMO coeff  " + "".join(f"{abs(v):7.2f}" for v in C[:, 2]))
print(f"LUMO at x = {x[2]:+.3f} (ethene's LUMO is at x = -1)")
Runs entirely in your browser, in an isolated worker. Nothing is sent to a server.

In methanal the filled π orbital has 0.85 of its amplitude on oxygen, but the empty π* has 0.85 on carbon. A nucleophile's electrons go into the LUMO, so they flow to carbon. The LUMO also lies lower than ethene's (α+0.62∣β∣\alpha + 0.62|\beta| against α+∣β∣\alpha + |\beta|), which is why a carbonyl group accepts nucleophiles that ignore an ordinary C=C bond.

Propenal adds a subtlety. The largest positive charge is on the carbonyl carbon C1 (+0.33), but the largest LUMO coefficient is on C3 (0.66), the far end of the C=C bond. Small, highly charged nucleophiles such as hydride donors and organolithium reagents, whose reactions are governed mainly by electrostatics, tend to add to C1 (1,2-addition). Larger, more polarisable nucleophiles such as thiols, amines and enolates, whose reactions are governed by orbital overlap, add to C3 (conjugate or 1,4-addition, the Michael reaction). Several modern cancer medicines, ibrutinib and osimertinib among them, carry a small C=C–C=O unit that makes a covalent bond to one particular cysteine thiol in their target protein by exactly this conjugate addition.

DefinitionsH

Addition, substitution and condensation

What happens after the first attack depends on what is attached to the carbonyl carbon.

Definition— nucleophilic addition

In aldehydes (RCHO) and ketones (R₂CO) the carbon carries only hydrogen and carbon, neither of which can leave. The tetrahedral alkoxide picks up a proton, and the overall result is addition across the C=O bond.

Water adds to give a hydrate, R₂C(OH)₂, reversibly. The equilibrium constant shows how electrophilic the carbonyl is: roughly 2×1032 \times 10^3 for methanal (in water it is almost all hydrate), about 1 for ethanal, and about 10−310^{-3} for propanone, whose two methyl groups both feed electron density to the carbon and crowd the tetrahedral product. Alcohols add in the same way to give hemiacetals; glucose spends nearly all its time in water as a six-membered ring formed when one of its own OH groups adds to its aldehyde (Biochemistry). Hydride donors such as sodium borohydride add H⁻ to carbon and reduce aldehydes and ketones to alcohols, and carbon nucleophiles such as Grignard reagents (Victor Grignard, Nobel Prize 1912) add a new C–C bond, one of the main ways chemists build carbon skeletons.

Definition— nucleophilic acyl substitution

In carboxylic acid derivatives (RCOX) the carbon carries a group X that can leave. The tetrahedral intermediate collapses, the C=O bond re-forms and X⁻ is expelled: overall, X is replaced by the nucleophile, by addition followed by elimination.

The better the leaving group, and the less the group X donates its lone pair into the C=O bond, the more reactive the derivative:

DerivativeExampleXReactivity towards water
acyl chlorideethanoyl chlorideClviolent, fast at room temperature
anhydrideethanoic anhydrideOCOCH₃fast
esterethyl ethanoateOCH₂CH₃slow without acid or base catalysis
amideethanamideNH₂very slow; days of heating with strong acid or base

The amide sits at the bottom because nitrogen's lone pair is delocalised into the carbonyl: the C–N bond has partial double-bond character, the amide is planar, and rotating about the C–N bond costs about 80 kJ/mol. That delocalisation is what makes proteins durable, and it can be switched off on purpose. In penicillin the amide is bent into a strained four-membered ring that cannot be planar; the lone pair can no longer delocalise, and the ring amide acylates a serine in a bacterial cell-wall enzyme far more readily than an ordinary amide could, which is how the drug kills bacteria. Aspirin works the same way: it is an ester that transfers its acetyl group to a serine of the enzyme cyclooxygenase.

Definition— condensation

A condensation joins two molecules with the loss of a small one, usually water. Carbonyl chemistry has three classic examples: an aldehyde or ketone with a primary amine gives an imine (C=N); a carboxylic acid with an alcohol gives an ester; and a carboxylic acid with an amine gives an amide.

Imine formation is everywhere in biochemistry. In the eye, the aldehyde retinal is held to the protein opsin by an imine with a lysine side chain; absorbing a photon twists one of retinal's C=C bonds, and that is the first chemical step of vision. Repeat a condensation at both ends of two molecules and you get a condensation polymer: polyesters such as PET from a diacid and a diol, and polyamides such as nylon-6,6 from a diacid and a diamine (see polymers in Lumenary Materials).

Worked examplesH

Enols and enolates

The carbonyl group makes its neighbours reactive too. A C–H bond next to C=O (on the α-carbon) is unusually acidic: propanone has pKaK_\mathrm{a} about 19, against about 50 for an alkane, because the anion left behind, the enolate, spreads its negative charge onto oxygen.

Example— Keto and enol forms

Propanone, CH₃COCH₃, and its enol, CH₂=C(OH)CH₃, are tautomers: isomers that interconvert by moving a proton and a double bond. They are different compounds, not two drawings of one, and the equilibrium lies far towards the keto form, which has the stronger C=O bond: only a few molecules in every billion are enol. In pentane-2,4-dione, where the enol's C=C is conjugated with the second carbonyl and its OH can hydrogen-bond to it, the enol is the major form in the pure liquid.

An enolate is a carbon nucleophile, and that makes it one of the most valuable species in synthesis. Its negative charge is shared between oxygen and the α-carbon, and with most electrophiles it reacts at carbon, making a new C–C bond.

  • In the aldol reaction, an enolate adds to the carbonyl of a second aldehyde or ketone, giving a β-hydroxy carbonyl compound (an "aldehyde-alcohol", hence the name); losing water then gives a C=C conjugated with the C=O (the aldol condensation). The enzyme aldolase runs the reverse reaction in glycolysis, splitting a six-carbon sugar into two three-carbon pieces.
  • In the Claisen condensation, an ester enolate attacks a second ester, which then loses its alkoxide by acyl substitution. Cells build fatty acids two carbons at a time with Claisen-type condensations of thioesters.

When a ketone has two different α-carbons, which enolate forms is a case of kinetic or thermodynamic control, exactly as in Reaction mechanisms. For 2-methylcyclohexanone, a strong, bulky base at −78 °C removes the more accessible proton fastest and the enolate is trapped before it can equilibrate (the kinetic enolate, with the less substituted C=C); a weaker base at room temperature lets the enolates interconvert, and the more substituted, more stable one wins.

IntuitionH

Aromatic rings: substitution, not addition

Molecular orbitals showed where benzene's special stability comes from: six π electrons exactly fill the three bonding orbitals of a six-membered ring, the first case of Hückel's 4n+24n + 2 rule, worth about 150 kJ/mol of extra stability. Chemically this means benzene does not behave like three alkenes. Cyclohexene decolourises bromine in seconds by adding Br₂ across its C=C bond; benzene ignores bromine unless a catalyst is present, and then it gives bromobenzene, C₆H₅Br, by substitution. Addition would destroy the aromatic sextet; substitution gives it back.

Definition— electrophilic aromatic substitution

The aromatic π system acts as a nucleophile towards a strong electrophile E⁺. In a slow first step the ring donates a pair of π electrons to E, giving a carbocation called the arenium ion (σ-complex, or Wheland intermediate), in which one carbon is sp³ and the positive charge is shared by the other five. In a fast second step a base removes the proton from the sp³ carbon and its C–H electrons restore the aromatic ring. Overall, H is replaced by E.

EHE+E+ H++slowfastbenzene + electrophilearenium ion (sp³ carbon at top)substituted benzene
Electrophilic aromatic substitution. The ring's π electrons attack the electrophile, giving the arenium ion, whose positive charge is spread over five carbons (the dashed arc). Losing H⁺ from the sp³ carbon then restores the aromatic sextet. The first step is slow because it gives up aromaticity; the second is fast because it regains it.

The art lies in making a strong enough electrophile, usually with a Lewis acid. For halogenation, iron(III) bromide polarises Br₂ so that one bromine becomes electrophilic. For Friedel–Crafts acylation (Charles Friedel and James Crafts, Paris, 1877), aluminium chloride pulls chloride from an acyl chloride to give an acylium ion, R–C≡O⁺, which attaches a ketone group to the ring. Sulfonation uses sulfur trioxide, and nitration the nitronium ion, NO₂⁺. These four reactions, and the coupling of aromatic rings with diazonium ions that makes azo dyes, are how most aromatic compounds of industry have been made since the nineteenth century.

ComputationC

Directing effects

A substituent already on the ring changes both how fast the next substitution goes and where it goes. The arenium ion explains both. Draw the three resonance structures for attack ortho (next to the substituent) or para (opposite it): one of them always puts the positive charge on the carbon carrying the substituent. Attack meta never does.

  • A substituent with a lone pair (–OH, –OR, –NH₂, –NHCOR) can donate it to that positive carbon, giving a fourth resonance structure in which every atom has an octet. Ortho and para attack are strongly favoured, and the ring reacts faster than benzene: these groups are activating, ortho/para-directing. Alkyl groups do the same, more weakly, by hyperconjugation.
  • An electron-withdrawing group (–NO₂, –CN, –CHO, –COR, –COOR, –CF₃) has a δ+ atom next to the ring. Ortho or para attack would put a positive charge right beside it, so those positions are hit hardest, and what remains is meta: these groups are deactivating, meta-directing.
  • Halogens are the exception that proves the rule: they withdraw electrons through the σ bond (deactivating), but donate a lone pair to the arenium ion (ortho/para-directing).

Wheland turned this argument into a number in 1942. The localisation energy of a position is the π energy lost when that carbon is pulled out of the π system, with two electrons, to bond to the electrophile: in Hückel terms, the π energy of the arene minus that of the arenium ion. By the Hammond postulate the arenium ion resembles the transition state of the slow step, so a lower localisation energy means a faster reaction. The program computes it for each position of four substituted rings, with standard textbook heteroatom parameters.

python
import numpy as np

def pi_energy(n_atoms, bonds, h, n_electrons):
    """Total Hueckel pi energy, as the coefficient of beta (E = n alpha + X beta, beta < 0)."""
    A = np.zeros((n_atoms, n_atoms))
    for i, j, k in bonds:
        A[i, j] = A[j, i] = k
    for i, hi in h.items():
        A[i, i] = hi
    x = np.sort(np.linalg.eigvalsh(A))[::-1]
    occ = np.zeros(n_atoms)
    occ[: n_electrons // 2] = 2
    return float(occ @ x)

def localisation(n_atoms, bonds, h, n_electrons, r):
    """Wheland's localisation energy for attack at atom r, in units of |beta|: the pi energy lost
    when atom r and two pi electrons are taken out of the pi system to bond to the electrophile."""
    keep = [i for i in range(n_atoms) if i != r]
    new = {old: k for k, old in enumerate(keep)}
    bonds2 = [(new[i], new[j], k) for i, j, k in bonds if r not in (i, j)]
    h2 = {new[i]: v for i, v in h.items() if i != r}
    return pi_energy(n_atoms, bonds, h, n_electrons) - pi_energy(n_atoms - 1, bonds2, h2, n_electrons - 2)

ring = [(i, (i + 1) % 6, 1.0) for i in range(6)]      # atom 0 carries the substituent
# Substituent models (standard textbook Hueckel parameters h and k):
molecules = {
    "benzene":        (6, ring, {}, 6),
    "methylbenzene":  (6, ring, {0: -0.5}, 6),                           # CH3 makes C0 electron-richer
    "methoxybenzene": (7, ring + [(0, 6, 0.8)], {6: 2.0}, 8),            # -O-: lone pair, 2 pi electrons
    "benzaldehyde":   (8, ring + [(0, 6, 1.0), (6, 7, 1.0)], {7: 1.0}, 8),  # -CH=O conjugated
    "pyridine":       (6, ring, {0: 0.5}, 6),                            # N in place of C0
}
print(f"{'':15s} {'ortho':>7s} {'meta':>7s} {'para':>7s}   localisation energy / |beta|")
for name, (n, bonds, h, ne) in molecules.items():
    L = [localisation(n, bonds, h, ne, r) for r in (1, 2, 3)]
    best = "all equal" if max(L) - min(L) < 1e-9 else ["ortho", "meta", "para"][int(np.argmin(L))]
    print(f"{name:15s} {L[0]:7.3f} {L[1]:7.3f} {L[2]:7.3f}   lowest: {best}")
print("(for pyridine, ortho/meta/para mean the 2-, 3- and 4-positions)")
Runs entirely in your browser, in an isolated worker. Nothing is sent to a server.

Benzene's localisation energy is 2.536∣β∣2.536|\beta| at every position. The methyl and methoxy groups lower it at ortho and para (2.35–2.41) and leave meta essentially unchanged: activating, ortho/para-directing. The aldehyde group raises it everywhere, least at meta (2.549), most at para: deactivating, meta-directing, with ortho close behind. Pyridine, where a nitrogen replaces one CH, behaves like benzene with a built-in acceptor, and is attacked at the 3-position, as observed. A model with two parameters per substituent and no electron repulsion gets every direction right.

ComputationC

Measuring substituent effects: the Hammett equation

In 1937 Louis Hammett at Columbia University found a way to put numbers on "electron-donating" and "electron-withdrawing". He took the ionisation of substituted benzoic acids in water as a standard and defined, for each substituent X in the meta or para position, the substituent constant

σX=log⁡10KXKH=pKa(H)−pKa(X).\sigma_\mathrm{X} = \log_{10}\frac{K_\mathrm{X}}{K_\mathrm{H}} = \mathrm{p}K_\mathrm{a}(\mathrm{H}) - \mathrm{p}K_\mathrm{a}(\mathrm{X}).

Positive σ means electron-withdrawing (the acid is stronger); negative means electron-donating. He then found that for many other reactions of the same substituted rings, rate or equilibrium constants obey

log⁡10kXkH=ρ σX,\log_{10}\frac{k_\mathrm{X}}{k_\mathrm{H}} = \rho\,\sigma_\mathrm{X},

a straight line whose slope, the reaction constant ρ, measures how sensitive the reaction is to electrons in the ring. Positive ρ means negative charge builds up in the transition state (or product); negative ρ means positive charge does. This is the linear free-energy relationship mentioned in Reaction mechanisms: logarithms of KK and kk are free energies, and the equation says substituent effects on two different reactions are proportional.

Here it is applied to the acidity of phenols, using measured pKaK_\mathrm{a} values and the σ values of the Hansch–Leo–Taft compilation.

python
import numpy as np

# Substituted phenols in water at 25 C: Hammett sigma (from benzoic acids), sigma-minus where it
# differs, and the measured pKa (rounded; compilations differ by a few hundredths).
phenols = {            # sigma, sigma_minus, pKa
    "H":      (0.00, None, 9.99),
    "4-CH3":  (-0.17, None, 10.26),
    "3-CH3":  (-0.07, None, 10.09),
    "4-OCH3": (-0.27, None, 10.21),
    "3-OCH3": (0.12, None, 9.65),
    "4-Cl":   (0.23, None, 9.41),
    "3-Cl":   (0.37, None, 9.12),
    "3-CN":   (0.56, None, 8.61),
    "3-NO2":  (0.71, None, 8.36),
    "4-CN":   (0.66, 1.00, 7.95),
    "4-NO2":  (0.78, 1.27, 7.15),
}
pKa_H = phenols["H"][2]
# Fit log(K/K_H) = pKa_H - pKa = rho * sigma, using every phenol except the two para acceptors.
fit = [n for n, (s, s_minus, p) in phenols.items() if s_minus is None]
sigma = np.array([phenols[n][0] for n in fit])
logK = np.array([pKa_H - phenols[n][2] for n in fit])
rho, c = np.polyfit(sigma, logK, 1)
r = np.corrcoef(sigma, logK)[0, 1]
print(f"rho = {rho:.2f}, intercept = {c:+.2f}, r = {r:.3f}  ({len(fit)} phenols)\n")
print("phenol   measured  predicted from sigma  from sigma-minus")
for n, (s, s_minus, p) in phenols.items():
    pred = pKa_H - (c + rho * s)
    extra = f"{pKa_H - (c + rho * s_minus):10.2f}" if s_minus is not None else ""
    print(f"{n:7s} {p:8.2f} {pred:12.2f}            {extra}")
Runs entirely in your browser, in an isolated worker. Nothing is sent to a server.

Nine phenols fall on a line with ρ = 2.09 and correlation coefficient 0.990: phenol ionisation is about twice as sensitive to substituents as benzoic acid ionisation, because the negative charge of a phenoxide sits on an oxygen attached directly to the ring rather than one atom further away. Two compounds miss badly. 4-Nitrophenol is predicted to have pKaK_\mathrm{a} 8.24 and actually has 7.15, more than ten times more acidic than the line allows; 4-cyanophenol misses by half a unit. Both have a para acceptor that can take the phenoxide's negative charge directly by resonance, which a benzoic acid cannot do. Hammett's successors handled this with a second scale, σ⁻, measured on reactions where such direct conjugation happens; with σ⁻ both phenols return to within 0.2 of the line. The same idea with positive charge gives σ⁺, the right scale for electrophilic aromatic substitution, where reaction constants are large and negative.

ExplanationH

Why medicines and dyes are built from these pieces

Dyes need conjugation. A molecule is coloured when its HOMO–LUMO gap falls in the visible range (Spectroscopy), and the gap shrinks as a π system grows. Aromatic rings and carbonyl groups are the easiest way to build long, rigid, stable π systems, and pairing an electron donor (an amino or hydroxy group on a ring) with an acceptor (a carbonyl or an azo group) shrinks the gap further. Alizarin, the red of madder root, is an anthraquinone: three fused rings with two carbonyls. In 1868 Carl Graebe and Carl Liebermann in Berlin made it from coal-tar anthracene, the first natural dye made synthetically. Indigo, the blue of denim, has two carbonyls conjugated through a C=C bond with two aromatic rings; Adolf von Baeyer worked out its structure and a synthesis, and BASF began selling synthetic indigo in 1897. Azo dyes, Ar–N=N–Ar′, are made by an electrophilic aromatic substitution in which the electrophile is an aryldiazonium ion; methyl orange, the acid–base indicator, and food colours such as Sunset Yellow FCF and Allura Red AC are azo dyes.

Medicines need shape, contacts and stability. A drug must fit a protein pocket, stick to it and survive the body for hours. Aromatic rings are flat and rigid, fill hydrophobic pockets, and stack against the rings of phenylalanine, tyrosine and tryptophan side chains. Amides are stable in water and provide a hydrogen-bond donor (N–H) and acceptor (C=O) in a fixed geometry, the same contacts that hold proteins together. Both are also easy to make: electrophilic substitution and the cross-coupling reactions of Synthesis and retrosynthesis decorate rings at will, and amide formation is reliable enough to be run by robots. The ease has a cost. Medicinal chemists noticed that molecules with many flat aromatic rings tend to be poorly soluble and more often fail in development, and since Lovering and colleagues' 2009 analysis the field has deliberately made drug candidates more three-dimensional, with more sp³ carbon (Medicinal chemistry).

Further reading

The professional view

In industry, carbonyl and aromatic chemistry is mostly a question of selectivity and conditions. Classical electrophilic substitutions use strong acids and stoichiometric Lewis acids that end up as waste, so process chemists replace them where they can with solid acid catalysts, with cross-couplings, or with C–H functionalisation, in which a metal catalyst converts a specific ring C–H bond directly. A well-known example is the BHC route to ibuprofen, which shortened the original six-step synthesis to three catalytic steps, the first of them a Friedel–Crafts acylation (Catalysis and green chemistry). Amide formation, the most frequent reaction in drug discovery, is being moved from wasteful activating reagents towards catalytic and enzymatic methods for the same reason.

Hammett's σ values survive as descriptors in modern structure–activity models, and substituent effects are now also computed directly. Programs predict pKaK_\mathrm{a} values and the most reactive site of a ring for electrophilic substitution from quantum-chemical calculations of proton affinities and arenium-ion energies, the modern version of Wheland's localisation energy (Computational chemistry), and machine-learned models trained on those calculations make the same predictions in milliseconds (AI for chemistry).

Common misconceptionsH

Common misconceptions

Misconception

"Nucleophiles attack the carbonyl oxygen because it has the lone pairs." Lone pairs make oxygen a nucleophile and a base, the site where protons and Lewis acids bind. Nucleophiles attack the carbon, where the C=O π* orbital is largest.

Misconception

"Benzene is cyclohexatriene, so it reacts like an alkene." Its six π electrons are delocalised over six equal bonds, and the aromatic stabilisation would be lost on addition. It reacts with electrophiles by substitution, and only with strong electrophiles.

Misconception

"Halogens direct ortho and para, so they must be activating." Direction and rate are separate questions. Halogens slow the reaction down by withdrawing electrons through the σ bond, yet their lone pairs still make ortho and para the least unfavourable positions.

Misconception

"A meta-director makes the meta position more reactive." It makes every position less reactive than in benzene; meta is simply hit least. Compare the program's benzaldehyde row: all three localisation energies are above benzene's.

Exercises

Exercises

1. Carbonyl and aromatic chemistry

Warm-upHuman

Which of these carboxylic acid derivatives reacts fastest with water at room temperature?

Choose one

2. Carbonyl and aromatic chemistry

CoreHuman

But-3-en-2-one, CH₂=CH–CO–CH₃, reacts with a thiol, RSH, in the presence of a mild base. At which carbon does the sulfur become bonded? (Number the chain from the CH₂= end as C4 … C1, so the carbonyl carbon is C2.)

Choose one

3. Carbonyl and aromatic chemistry

CoreHuman

2-Methylcyclohexanone is treated with a strong, bulky base at −78 °C, and the enolate is trapped before it can equilibrate. Which enolate is formed mainly?

Choose one

4. Carbonyl and aromatic chemistry

CoreHuman

Which of these substituents on a benzene ring direct an incoming electrophile to the ortho and para positions? Select all that apply.

Choose all that apply

5. Carbonyl and aromatic chemistry

StretchHuman

4-Methoxybenzaldehyde undergoes electrophilic bromination on the ring. Where does the bromine go mainly? (Number the ring from the carbon carrying the CHO group as C1, so OCH₃ is on C4.)

Choose one

6. Carbonyl and aromatic chemistry

CoreHuman

A reaction of substituted benzene compounds has Hammett reaction constant ρ = +2.5. How many times faster does the compound with a 3-nitro group (σ = 0.71) react than the unsubstituted compound? Give the nearest whole number.

7. Carbonyl and aromatic chemistry

StretchComputational

Naphthalene, two fused benzene rings, undergoes electrophilic substitution mainly at position 1 (next to a ring-fusion carbon) rather than position 2. Check this with Wheland's localisation energy. pi_energy(bonds, n_atoms, n_electrons) is written for you. Complete localisation_energy(bonds, n_atoms, n_electrons, r): remove atom r and every bond to it, renumber the remaining atoms from 0, and return the arene's π energy minus the arenium ion's (which has two fewer π electrons), in units of ∣β∣|\beta|. The tests use benzene and naphthalene, whose atoms 8 and 9 are the ring-fusion carbons.

Runs entirely in your browser, in an isolated worker. Nothing is sent to a server.

8. Carbonyl and aromatic chemistry

CoreComputational

Anilinium ions, ArNH₃⁺, are acids too. Write hammett_fit(sigma, log_ratio), returning (rho, intercept, r) for the least-squares line log⁡10(KX/KH)=ρσ+c\log_{10}(K_\mathrm{X}/K_\mathrm{H}) = \rho\sigma + c with correlation coefficient rr, and largest_residual(names, sigma, log_ratio), returning the name of the compound farthest from the line. The tests use measured pKaK_\mathrm{a} values of ten substituted anilinium ions (so log⁡10(KX/KH)=4.60−pKa\log_{10}(K_\mathrm{X}/K_\mathrm{H}) = 4.60 - \mathrm{p}K_\mathrm{a}): find the outlier, then fit the other nine.

Runs entirely in your browser, in an isolated worker. Nothing is sent to a server.

Further reading and resources