Skip to content
LumenaryAcademy
Start 50 min

Structures

Why things stand up — loads, tension and compression, beams, columns, arches and trusses, and a bridge you can build and test.

Code tested · 2AI-draftedAwaiting review by a mechanical engineer

Your guides: Chloe · The Designer, Margaret · The Test Engineer, Gideon · The Checker

MotivationH

Why doesn't it fall down?

You are probably sitting on a chair, inside a building. The chair holds you up, the floor holds the chair up, the walls or columns hold the floor up, and the foundations hold the walls up. Outside, bridges carry lorries over rivers and towers hold up antennas in the wind. We hardly ever think about them, but each one is working all the time, carrying weight safely down to the ground.

A structure is anything built to carry loads: a bridge, a building, a chair, a bicycle frame, a bookshelf, even a bird's nest. Its designers ask: what loads must it carry, which way do the forces travel through it, and is each part strong enough, and stiff enough, for its share? In this lesson you will meet the two kinds of force inside every structure, the shapes engineers use again and again, and the reason triangles are everywhere. Then you will compare beam shapes in Python and build a bridge of your own.

IntuitionH

Loads, tension and compression

Loads

The forces a structure carries are called loads. Engineers sort them into a few kinds:

  • Its own weight (the dead load): a concrete bridge deck is very heavy, and it is there all the time.
  • What it holds up (the live load): people, furniture, cars, trains, books on a shelf. These come and go.
  • Nature's loads: wind pushing on a tower, snow piling on a roof, the ground shaking in an earthquake, and even the Sun, which warms a long steel bridge so that it grows a few centimetres longer on a summer afternoon.

A good design carries all of these, in their worst combinations, with plenty to spare.

Pulling and squashing

Inside a structure, every part is being either pulled or squashed (and some are being bent, which, as you will see, is both at once).

Definition— tension and compression

A part is in tension when the forces on it pull it apart, trying to stretch it. A rope holding a swing, the cables of a suspension bridge and the spokes of a bicycle wheel are in tension.

A part is in compression when the forces on it push it together, trying to squash it. The legs of a chair, the columns of a building and the stones of an arch are in compression.

ropetension:pulled, it stretchescolumncompression:squashed, it shortensloadtop: squeezedbottom: stretchedbending:both at once
Left: a rope pulled from both ends is in tension and gets a tiny bit longer. Middle: a column pressed from both ends is in compression and gets a tiny bit shorter. Right: a beam carrying a load bends; its top is squeezed and its bottom is stretched, so lines drawn across it crowd together at the top and spread apart at the bottom.

You can see bending for yourself with a long kitchen sponge. Draw straight lines across one side of it with a felt-tip pen, rest it across two cups, and press down gently in the middle. The lines along the top crowd together (compression) while the lines along the bottom spread apart (tension). Somewhere in the middle there is a layer that is neither squeezed nor stretched.

Materials have favourites

Stone, brick and concrete are very strong in compression but crack easily when pulled. Rope, wire and cable are wonderful in tension but useless in compression: try pushing something with a rope! Steel and wood are good at both. That is why so much modern building uses reinforced concrete: steel bars are cast inside the concrete where the tension will be, so the concrete takes the squashing and the steel the pulling. You will meet many more materials in Lumenary Materials' materials around us.

DefinitionsH

Beams, columns, arches, cables and trusses

Engineers carry loads with a handful of shapes, used again and again.

beamcolumnarchtruss
Four ways to carry a load. A beam bends between its supports. A column is squashed along its length. An arch turns a downward load into compression that follows its curve and pushes outwards on its ends. A truss is a frame of straight bars joined in triangles.

Beams. A beam carries loads across a gap by bending: a shelf, a floor joist, a simple concrete bridge. As the sponge showed, its top is squeezed and its bottom stretched. What matters most is how deep it is: a plank laid flat sags, but the same plank on its edge hardly bends. That is why steel beams are shaped like a capital I, with material far from the middle, where the squeezing and stretching are greatest.

Columns. A column carries a load straight down by being squashed: a chair leg, a pillar, the steel frame of a skyscraper. Short, fat columns are very hard to break. Long, thin ones have a weakness: press the ends of a drinking straw or a long strip of card together and, long before it is crushed, it bows out sideways. That sudden sideways bowing is called buckling, and it is the reason tall columns are thick, or braced from the side.

Arches. An arch is a curved shape that turns a downward load into compression running along its curve. That makes it perfect for stone and brick, which are strong when squeezed. The price is that an arch pushes outwards at its feet, so it needs solid ground or heavy walls, called abutments, to push against. While an arch is being built it cannot stand on its own; its stones rest on a temporary wooden frame until the last, central stone, the keystone, locks them together.

Cables. A hanging cable is an upside-down arch: it carries load in pure tension. Suspension bridges hang their roads from cables draped over tall towers. The cables pull, the towers are squashed, and huge anchor blocks hold the cable ends in the ground.

Trusses. A truss is a frame of straight bars joined into triangles. Each bar is only pulled or pushed along its length, never bent, so a truss carries big loads with very little material. Look for trusses in railway bridges, roofs, cranes and electricity pylons.

IntuitionH

Why triangles are strong

Here is a safe experiment that explains a hundred structures. Cut seven strips of thick card, each about 2 cm wide and 15 cm long, and ask an adult to punch a hole near each end. Join four strips into a square with paper fasteners (split pins) through the holes, and three more into a triangle.

Now push gently on one corner of each. The square folds over into a leaning diamond shape, and then flat. The triangle does not move at all.

square: folds overtriangle: keeps its shapeadd a diagonal:two triangles, rigid
Left: four bars pinned at their corners can lean over into a diamond without any bar changing length. Middle: a triangle cannot change shape unless one of its bars stretches or shortens. Right: one diagonal bar turns the square into two triangles, and it becomes rigid too.

Why? As the square folds, every bar keeps its length; only the angles at the corners change. A triangle is different: its three side lengths allow only one shape, so its angles are locked. To change its shape you would have to stretch or squash a bar, and a good bar resists that very strongly.

Add one diagonal to the square and it becomes two triangles, just as rigid. You can spot this trick everywhere: the diagonal brace on a farm gate, the triangles of a bicycle frame, the criss-cross bracing on a pylon or crane, the roof trusses of a house.

Worked examplesH

Famous structures and what they teach

People in every part of the world have built structures that still teach engineers today.

StructureWhere and whenHow it carries loadWhat it teaches
Pont du GardFrance, about 2000 years ago (Roman)Three tiers of stone arches carrying a water channelIts arch stones were laid without mortar: each is held by the squeeze of its neighbours.
Zhaozhou BridgeChina, about 600 CE, designed by Li ChunOne long, flat stone arch, with four small arches through its endsThe small openings make it lighter and let floods through; it has stood for about 1400 years.
The Iron BridgeEngland, 1779A cast-iron archCast iron cracks when pulled, so its builders chose the shape that keeps it squeezed.
Forth BridgeScotland, 1890Giant steel cantilever trussesTriangulated arms can reach across a deep sea inlet.
Q'eswachaka bridgePeru, rebuilt every yearA suspension bridge of woven grass ropeEverything is in tension; Quechua communities keep up the Inca tradition of rebuilding it together each year.
Living root bridgesMeghalaya, IndiaRoots of rubber fig trees, guided across streams by Khasi villagersA structure that grows, and gets stronger with age.
1915 Çanakkale BridgeTürkiye, 2022A deck hung from cables over two towersAs of 2026, the longest main span of any suspension bridge: 2023 m.
Burj KhalifaUnited Arab Emirates, 2010A concrete core braced by three wings in a Y shapeThe tallest building in the world as of 2026 (828 m); the wings brace the core like a tripod's legs.

In 1887, to show how the Forth Bridge would work, its builders staged a photograph of a "human cantilever". Two men sat on chairs with both arms stretched out sideways, each hand gripping a stick braced against the chair. Between their inner hands hung a short plank, and on it sat Kaichi Watanabe, a young Japanese engineer who had studied in Glasgow. Their arms were in tension, the sticks in compression, and piles of bricks at the outer ends stopped the men tipping forwards. The real bridge works the same way, with steel tubes as the sticks and steel ties as the arms.

ComputationC

Beam shapes in Python

Why does a plank on its edge bend so much less than the same plank lying flat? Engineers measure a beam's resistance to bending with a number worked out from the shape of its cross-section. For a solid rectangle it is

bending stiffness=width×depth×depth×depth12.\text{bending stiffness} = \frac{\text{width} \times \text{depth} \times \text{depth} \times \text{depth}}{12}.

The depth appears three times, the width only once. So making a beam twice as deep makes it eight times stiffer, but making it twice as wide only makes it twice as stiff. The program below compares five shapes, each made from about the same amount of material. Press Run:

python
# How well do different beam shapes resist bending?
# All sizes are in millimetres. Every beam is made from about the same amount of material.

def stiffness(width, depth):
    """The bending stiffness of a solid rectangular beam: width x depth x depth x depth / 12."""
    return width * depth ** 3 / 12

# First, one plank, standing taller and taller (the width stays 60 mm):
print("depth   stiffness compared with the 10 mm plank")
for depth in [10, 20, 30]:
    print(f"{depth:3} mm  {stiffness(60, depth) / stiffness(60, 10):4.0f} times")

# Now five shapes, each made from about 600 square millimetres of material.
shapes = [
    # name,                                   material (mm2),     stiffness
    ("flat plank, 60 wide and 10 deep",       60 * 10,            stiffness(60, 10)),
    ("the same plank on its edge",            10 * 60,            stiffness(10, 60)),
    ("square bar, 24.5 by 24.5",              24.5 * 24.5,        stiffness(24.5, 24.5)),
    # A square tube is a 40 x 40 square with a 32 x 32 hole: subtract the hole.
    ("square tube, 40 by 40, walls 4 thick",  40 * 40 - 32 * 32,  stiffness(40, 40) - stiffness(32, 32)),
    # An I-beam is a 40 x 50 rectangle with two 17.5 x 40 gaps cut out of its sides.
    ("I-beam, 40 wide and 50 deep",           40 * 50 - 2 * 17.5 * 40,
                                                                  stiffness(40, 50) - 2 * stiffness(17.5, 40)),
]

flat = shapes[0][2]
print()
print("shape                                 material   times stiffer than the flat plank")
for name, material, stiff in shapes:
    times = stiff / flat
    print(f"{name:37} {material:5.0f} mm2  {times:5.1f}  " + "#" * round(times))
Runs entirely in your browser, in an isolated worker. Nothing is sent to a server.

With the same 600 square millimetres of material, the plank on its edge is 36 times stiffer than the flat plank, and the I-beam is 46 times stiffer. The I-beam wins because it puts most of its material in two flanges, far from the middle, where the squeezing and stretching are greatest, and keeps only a thin web to join them. The square tube does the same trick in every direction, which is why bicycle frames and scaffolding are made of tubes.

You can test the same idea with a sheet of paper. Lay it flat across a gap between two books and it sags under a single coin. Now fold it back and forth into a zigzag, like a paper fan, and lay it across the gap again. Exactly the same paper can now hold a whole row of coins, because the folds have given it depth. Corrugated cardboard and the ridged steel sheets on factory roofs use the same trick.

Worked examplesH

Build and test a bridge

Now it is your turn. The challenge: build a light bridge that spans a 30 cm gap between two piles of books and carries as many coins as possible.

model bridgebooksbookscup of coinstraygap: 30 cm
A test set-up for a model bridge. The bridge rests on two equal piles of books on a table, a paper cup hangs from the middle of the bridge, and coins are added to the cup one at a time. A tray underneath catches the cup when the bridge gives way.

Materials. Choose one: sheets of paper and sticky tape; or dry spaghetti and white (PVA) glue or masking tape. Do not use a hot-glue gun unless an adult is doing the gluing, because the glue and the nozzle are hot enough to burn.

Stay safe. Dry spaghetti snaps into sharp little splinters that can fly up, so wear safety glasses or goggles while you build and test, and work with an adult. Test on a low table, put a tray or a folded towel under the cup, and keep your hands and feet out from under the bridge while it is loaded.

Design. Sketch two or three ideas first. Use triangles to stop the bridge folding, depth to stop it bending, and short pieces for parts that will be squashed. Glue joints well: most model bridges fail at a joint.

Test. Weigh your bridge on a kitchen scale. Hang the cup from the middle, then add coins gently, one at a time, and count until the bridge gives way. Watch closely, or film it on a phone: where did it fail, and was that part being pulled or squashed?

Score. To find the load, weigh ten of your coins to learn the mass of one, then multiply by the number of coins. The fairest score is the strength-to-weight ratio: the mass it held divided by the bridge's own mass. A 40 g bridge that held 600 g of coins scores 15: it carried fifteen times its own weight.

Improve. Make one change, guided by what broke, and test again. That loop of idea, build, test and improve is the heart of engineering, and the next lesson, How things are made, is all about it.

ExplanationH

Structures in the real world

Real structural engineers work just as you did, with bigger numbers. They work out every load a structure might meet, including a rare great storm or earthquake, and design with a margin of safety, so that it could carry more than it ever should have to. They calculate the force in every part by computer, test materials and models in laboratories, and inspect bridges and buildings for decades. Building codes in every country set the rules, because people crossing a bridge trust that someone has checked it.

Later in Lumenary ME you will learn to calculate those forces yourself: balancing forces and turning effects in Statics and equilibrium, the force in every bar of a truss in Trusses and frames, and how beams bend and columns buckle in Axial load, torsion and bending and Deflection and buckling.

Common misconceptionsH

Common misconceptions

Misconception

"A strong structure has no forces in it." A bridge standing still carries enormous forces all the time. It stays still because those forces are balanced, and because each part is strong enough for its share.

Misconception

"More material always makes a stronger structure." Shape matters as much as the amount of material. The same paper folded into a zigzag holds many more coins, and the same plank is 36 times stiffer standing on its edge. Extra material also adds weight, which the structure must then carry too.

Misconception

"Concrete is strong, so it can take any load." Concrete is very strong when squeezed but cracks when pulled. Concrete beams and floors have steel bars cast inside them, placed where the tension will be.

Misconception

"Buildings and bridges never move." They move a little all the time. Tall towers sway gently in the wind, and long bridges grow longer on hot days, which is why bridges have expansion joints: the toothed gaps you may have noticed in the road at each end. Structures are designed to move a little, safely, rather than to crack.

Exercises

Exercises

Most of these ask you to think; a few ask for a little arithmetic, and the last one asks you to change a few lines of Python.

1. Structures

Warm-upHuman

Which of these parts are in tension (being pulled)? Choose all that apply.

Choose all that apply

2. Structures

Warm-upHuman

A wooden farm gate is a rectangle of bars with one extra bar running diagonally across it. Why is the diagonal bar there?

Choose one

3. Structures

CoreHuman

A shelf is a plank 200 mm wide and 15 mm deep. Kwame glues a second, identical plank on top of it, so the shelf is now 200 mm wide and 30 mm deep.

Using the rule in the lesson, how many times stiffer is the new shelf than the old one?

4. Structures

CoreHuman

The Iron Bridge in England (1779) was made of cast iron, which is strong when squeezed but brittle and weak when pulled. Why did its builders make it an arch?

Choose one

5. Structures

CoreHuman

A concrete beam rests on a wall at each end and carries a floor. Where should the steel reinforcing bars go?

Choose one

6. Structures

CoreHuman

Ana's spaghetti bridge has a mass of 48 g. It held 160 coins before it broke, and each coin has a mass of 6 g.

What is its strength-to-weight ratio (the mass it held divided by its own mass)?

7. Structures

CoreComputational

A ruler is 30 mm wide and 3 mm thick. You can bend it across its flat side, or try to bend it on its edge, when it is 3 mm wide and 30 mm deep.

Complete the program by replacing each ... with a calculation (not a final number):

  • stiffness(width, depth) should return width × depth × depth × depth ÷ 12;
  • times should be how many times stiffer the ruler is on its edge than flat.
Runs entirely in your browser, in an isolated worker. Nothing is sent to a server.

Further reading and resources